By CONNIE ZEIGLER / Contributing editor
Just a few weeks after the Indianapolis Board of School Commissioners announced a plan in 1970 to phase out Shortridge High School (and close Crispus Attucks High School), due to the U. S. Justice Department’s lawsuit against the IPS system of school segregation, two members of the staff at Shortridge came up with a plan of their own:
An exchange program meant to expose students from an all-white school in Northern Indiana to the, at that time, integrated, 65% Black, Shortridge. At the same time, offer Shortridge students a chance to share with an all-white community the importance of integration and the results of racism.
On March 7, 1970, The Indianapolis Star announced the “Shortridge-Goshen High School Exchange Program.” That day 12 Shortridge students traveled north to the all-white high school in the all-white city of Goshen for a week of experiencing life in a different sort of community, and for a chance to educate white students about Black life and school integration. The 12 students, eight Black and four white, were chosen at random from among 38 applicants; four additional young Black men were included for one day.
The Indianapolis students were chaperoned by Roy Aberson, who had been working at Shortridge since 1940, according to the school’s Daily Echo newspaper. Aberson had started as a track and field coach and was so successful he became locally famous; in the 1950s he began to teach history and coach football at the school. By the time he accompanied students to Goshen, he was Shortridge’s “human relations counselor.”

Aberson was both Jewish and a collector of African art. During a question-and-answer session at a student convocation in Goshen he was asked by a student how much he paid for an art piece: “Couldn’t you try to jew him down?” Aberson, who had just finished playing a recording by Black actor, Ossie Davis, about words that carry negative connotations, educated the entire student body with a three-word response: “Now that’s racism.” Then he calmly explained why.
Over the course of the week, the students from Shortridge lived with Goshen families and willingly bore the burden of showing and explaining what racism meant to them. A slide show that they brought did not pull punches, sharing the Black experience of troops in Vietnam and talking about white flight from Gary (something the Indianapolis students were also seeing in their own city). One slide carried the caption, “Black is seeing a white man get rich doing what your grandfather did for nothing.” Another, which caused some titters in the crowd of white students who had probably never noticed that Blacks were under-represented in media, was simply captioned, “Black is waiting for a soul brother to be on a deodorant commercial.”
The Indianapolis group met with Goshen students who already had spent a week in Indianapolis in February as the reciprocal part of the exchange. Those students gave Roy Aberson a plaque for “services above and beyond the call of duty.” Along with attending classes at Shortridge, the Goshen students had met the young Indianapolis mayor, Richard C. Lugar, and did an interview with WFBM TV personality Jim Gerard, according to an article in The Indianapolis Star on March 10, 1970. In that article, one of the students remarked that they had “wanted to experience integration” and noted what seemed to be an “easy relationship” between Black and white students at Shortridge. Another said, “It would be a shame to close a school that has such good integration.”
The Indianapolis students were disappointed that Goshen’s principal, John Johnson, had made it clear that he did not want to meet them, though he finally acquiesced and did so on the last day of the school week.
On that last Friday, according to The Star, 90 students at Goshen came to school wearing, as a protest, clothes that did not meet the dress code. No Indianapolis students were involved, and the “demonstrators” said their protest had nothing to do with the exchange program, but at least one Goshen mother was quoted in the article: “Our kids came back from Indianapolis with big ideas about how they should be able to get away with everything the students at Shortridge do.”
On the other hand, at the end of the exchange program, the Shortridge students were impressed with how much cushier the Goshen students had it. They could drive their own cars to school, go home for lunch, leave their lockers unlocked and play basketball during lunch. And the classwork was easier, they said.
The vice-principals from the two schools, who had coordinated the exchange, “heralded [it] as a worthwhile attempt at improving interracial and intercommunity relationships,” according to The Indianapolis News on March 16, but they suspected that there was not much chance of it continuing. They were right. There were no more student exchanges between the schools.
Still, the adage is “any press is good press” and the exchange garnered several positive articles in local newspapers. Did it impact the Indianapolis Board of School Commissioners’ decision on March 10, 1970, to cancel the phaseout of Shortridge High School? Probably not, but it did highlight Shortridge as a positive experience for white students. The school commissioners retained their plan to close the existing Crispus Attucks school and open a new integrated Crispus Attucks in the suburbs (neither of which ever happened). Ultimately both schools survived for a while, but enrollment dropped and white flight caused a continually decreasing percentage of white students in the mix at Shortridge.
In 1973, Justice S. Hugh Dillin ordered the Indianapolis Public Schools to begin busing students between schools to achieve racial desegregation. He expanded that busing order in 1981, requiring Indianapolis to send 5,600 Black students each year to six suburban school districts.
Roy Aberson, the man who had coached and taught and counseled at the school for 40 years, and who had spent one important week teaching students at another school about racism, retired in 1980, a year before that expanded busing order.
Shortridge High School closed in 1981. It reopened as a middle school in the mid-1980s. In 2009 high school classes started once again in the school. Eventually the middle school was dropped from the location and it again became Shortridge High School. It is still an operating high school today.
This feature as it appeared in the November 2026 print edition of Urban Times contained, in its final paragraph, an error about the current status of Shortridge High School. The error has been corrected in this posting.



